All Narfed Up photography and words by Bryan Villarin

reCAPTCHA - yay or nay?

I’m utilizing reCAPTCHA to stop comment and/or email spam by “reading books”. (If you don’t know what a CAPTCHA is, their website explains it comprehensively.) Installing the plugin and getting the API keys were simple.

The book pages are being photographically scanned, and then, to make them searchable, transformed into text using “Optical Character Recognition” (OCR). The transformation into text is useful because scanning a book produces images, which are difficult to store on small devices, expensive to download, and cannot be searched. The problem is that OCR is not perfect.

reCAPTCHA improves the process of digitizing books by sending words that cannot be read by computers to the Web in the form of CAPTCHAs for humans to decipher. More specifically, each word that cannot be read correctly by OCR is placed on an image and used as a CAPTCHA. This is possible because most OCR programs alert you when a word cannot be read correctly.

This seems like a win/win situation, right? So why don’t more websites (i.e. blogs) utilize this service?


7 Comments

My only issue with Captcha (and moreso reCaptcha) is the fact that it’s sometimes difficult to actually see what the words are, requiring numerous attempts more and more frustrating.

Posted by Chris on 25 June 2007 @ 10pm

I’ve been using an Akismet and Spam Karma combination and it works great.

I’m not a big fan of any extra for the commenter.

Posted by Nick on 26 June 2007 @ 5am

@Chris: I’ve since disabled it because of that fact.

@Nick: I’ve gone the more minimalistic route, too.

Posted by Bryan on 27 June 2007 @ 2pm

FAN-tacular. Although I should apologize for my piss poor grammar with my earlier comment. My bad.

Posted by Chris on 27 June 2007 @ 8pm

How well did reCAPTCHA work while you had it installed? Honestly, I hate captchas too, but I’ll be going on a bit of an extended vacation soon and am thinking about adding this as an extra layer of protection while I’m gone. At least it’ll contribute to a good cause too, right?

Posted by James on 19 July 2007 @ 11pm

@James: I think it worked well. Nothing really comes through anyway, since I don’t get too much traffic. ;)

Wherever you’re going for vacation, have a great time!

Posted by Bryan on 19 July 2007 @ 11pm

In that case, I think I’ll use it while I’m away. As for the vacation, I’m sure that I’ll enjoy it. Thanks!

Posted by James on 20 July 2007 @ 11am

Leave a Comment

Back from San Diego Review: Canon cameras rock!